Mexican restaurants

Jimmy’s Mexican Restaurant

4.2 56 reviews Closed 410 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11218, United States

Discover this place

Jimmy’s Mexican Restaurant is located in Brooklyn, offering a diverse menu that reflects traditional Mexican cuisine with a local touch. The restaurant features classic dishes such as pozole, mole de olla, and a variety of caldos, including chicken soup with vegetables and tortilla soup. Guests can also enjoy an assortment of crispy tacos, featuring fillings like tinga, al pastor, and carne enchilada. Tamales with mild tomatillo or red sauces add to the authentic experience. The menu extends to unique items like the chopped cheese sandwich and churro sundae, blending familiar flavors with Mexican influences.

The atmosphere is casual and approachable, suitable for everyday dining. Situated on Church Avenue, Jimmy’s provides a straightforward setting where the emphasis rests on the quality and variety of its food. Its combination of hearty soups, tacos, and traditional staples makes it a notable presence in the local dining scene, appealing to both those seeking comfort food and those exploring Mexican culinary traditions.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Jimmy’s Mexican Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Jimmy’s Mexican Restaurant

4.2

56 reviews

100%

16%

18%

Review highlights

Based on 56 reviews

Jimmy’s Mexican Restaurant in Brooklyn consistently receives praise for its authentic and flavorful Mexican cuisine, with a diverse menu that includes popular dishes such as chilaquiles, birria tacos, tamales, and enchiladas. Reviewers often highlight the freshness and quality of the ingredients, as well as the generous portion sizes. The restaurant is noted for its warm, friendly service and efficient staff, creating a welcoming atmosphere for both dine-in and takeout experiences. Outdoor seating that accommodates pets adds to its appeal. A common observation concerns the cash-only policy, which may be inconvenient for some patrons. Additionally, specialty items like tamales are praised but sometimes limited to weekends. Overall, Jimmy’s Mexican Restaurant is recognized for delivering a satisfying and genuine Mexican dining experience with attentive service and a community-focused vibe.

Brenda M

Feb 07, 2026

Great Mexican restaurant and the food here is amazing! The people who own this restaurant are really nice and they always have different specials everyday but they are a cash only restaurant. They have several varieties of Mexican food but I recommend the costillas con arroz y frijoles. It is tasty and filling. They also have different desserts which my favorite is the churros! Me and my partner come here most of the time and they never disappoint with the portions. They are a great addition to the community as I don’t see many Mexican restaurants around here to sit, eat, and enjoy!

Nay Oropeza

Feb 01, 2026

I just ate here for the first time and it was amazing. I had chilaquiles with steak and the flavor was so authentic. My husband ordered the nachos with chorizo and he loved them. We ordered the birria tacos to share and they were incredible. I tried the horchata water it was great. The staff was super friendly and helpful. The service was quick. We were able to sit outside with our dog and had no issues at all. I am only sad, I had not tried their food before. This is definitely one of my favorite restaurants in the area now.

Jeremy Feliciano

Jan 10, 2026

This place does not disappoint. Really fresh tasting food. Holds up well when delivered too

Sabiha Bary

Jan 09, 2026

Amazing tamales! Loved the tamales de chile rojo and tamales de mole! Apparently the tamales are only available on weekends. We also got the enchiladas de rojo con pollo, which was very good too. I only wish the cheese was melted when they served it. Im excited to go back and try their other dishes !

Safi Bi

Jan 08, 2026

We came in here for a quick lunch and got the Sopes Con Cecina and they were delicious. We got our food pretty quickly. Would definitely come back.

Arleny Henriquez

Jan 07, 2026

This place has so cute. The food is soo good. We had tacos and the tortilla was perfectly warm fluffy and flavorful. The steak was seasoned so well! 10/10

Nunia

Jan 03, 2026

Sat for dinner in a Sunday. Low fuss, great food, and a great way to end a long week. Pozole was amazing 10/10.

Josie & Greg

Dec 10, 2025

Jimmy’s Mexican Restaurant serves great food! Their tacos and burritos are packed with flavor, and the margaritas are perfectly refreshing. The food is fresh, the portions are generous, and the atmosphere is welcoming. Highly recommend for anyone craving delicious Mexican cuisine!